Volvo Community Forum. The Forums of the Volvo Owners Club

Forum Rules Volvo Owners Club About VOC Volvo Gallery Links Volvo History Volvo Press
Go Back   Volvo Owners Club Forum > "General Topics" > General Volvo and Motoring Discussions

Notices

General Volvo and Motoring Discussions This forum is for messages of a general nature about Volvos that are not covered by other forums and other motoring related matters of interest. Users will need to register to post/reply.

Information
  • VOC Members: There is no login facility using your VOC membership number or the details from page 3 of the club magazine. You need to register in the normal way
  • AOL Customers: Make sure you check the 'Remember me' check box otherwise the AOL system may log you out during the session. This is a known issue with AOL.
  • AOL, Yahoo and Plus.net users. Forum owners such as us are finding that AOL, Yahoo and Plus.net are blocking a lot of email generated from forums. This may mean your registration activation and other emails will not get to you, or they may appear in your spam mailbox

Thread Informations

Dispute Advice

Views : 1155

Replies : 18

Users Viewing This Thread :  

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old Sep 13th, 2018, 19:00   #1
Boxybutgood
New Member
 

Last Online: Sep 17th, 2018 22:44
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: South Lincs
Default Dispute Advice

Hello

Not a Volvo issue but a general one; last Jan I had the h/g's replaced on my Subaru as they were deemed about to fail. Work carried out by a Subaru MD (who I trust and have been very fair for a number of years). The other week the car didn't seem quite right and a quick inspection showed radiator expansion tank full of oily water, car coughed on start up, etc. MD discovered the thermostat (replaced when h/g's done) had failed. As all tests carried out could not show h/gs had failed we had the engine out and we have found a cracked head.

Their position is that as we cannot prove the thermostat failed before the head cracked they are not liable. They have suggested an independent engineer inspect the head but I can't see how this can prove the sequence of events.

To me it's clear cut and if it came to court the balance of probabilities has to be the thermostat causing the crack due to overheating. As I paid by credit card I could make a Section 75 claim but before I go further does anyone have any similar experience here?

Any thoughts gratefully received.
__________________
Now; 55 Subaru Outback auto - just as good as you've heard, 55 Vauxhall Astra 1.8 auto Estate - a lot better than you're thinking

Previous; 740GL, 740GLE auto, 745GLE auto, 945S auto, still looking....
Boxybutgood is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Sep 13th, 2018, 19:51   #2
volvoid
Monster Raving Loony
 
volvoid's Avatar
 

Last Online: Nov 12th, 2018 21:03
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: hitchin
Default

It’s very reasonable of them to suggest independent inspection.
One cant expect the garage to hold their hands up and say its their fault, very expensive, but their insurance should cover it. Did they supply all parts used ? If not theres another can of worms, not our fault guv, must have been that dodgy xyz.
Thermostats tend not to fail often and then generally do so fullly open, but not always.
I wonder what cracked the head ? Overheating ? Some failure in doing up bolts correctly ? Is the engine still intact or has it been dismantled ?
__________________
1994 850 2.0 bought at 32,000 miles used daily now 45,000. Still like a nearly-new car
2004 filthy polluting diesel VW
volvoid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Sep 13th, 2018, 19:51   #3
kenny
Master Member
 

Last Online: Dec 16th, 2020 21:33
Join Date: May 2009
Location: kirknewton
Default

I agree with you that a faulty thermostat is the most plausible cause however as the garage or the defendant is refusing you claim, you the claimant need to prove this. If it went to a court you will need an expert opinion such as an engineers report. As a layman the judge will not look at your opinion as strongly as that of the garage full of qualified mechanics and probably rule in their favour. Bring in an engineers report in your favour and the garage will possibly do the repair rather than go to the expense of fighting it and if they do you have evidence on your side to persuade a judge.
As for a Section 75 claims, yes they are great but only if you are in the right. They will help you if the dealer has gone bust or refuses to help you. Your card company will also want some proof that the dealer and they have a case to answer. With an engineers report they may just tell the dealer to fix it or they will and then take the money out their account.

I have had two full refunds for cars I bought with support from my credit company via a section 75 One had a fake service history. Easy to prove the stamps in the book did not match the dealers records. The other one a faulty gearbox. I had a report from a BMW dealer down the road saying the car needed a £6,000 Gearbox.

You need an engineers report. It might cost but if it is in your favour you can claim that cost back as well. Good luck I hope it goes your way.
kenny is offline   Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to kenny For This Useful Post:
Old Sep 14th, 2018, 14:53   #4
Austin160
Master Member
 

Last Online: Oct 29th, 2021 14:42
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: Cardiff
Default Dispute advice.

For what it's worth, I am in agreement with the responses to date, and sympathise with your situation.
What I would question from your original post is the statement relating to the faulty thermostat leading to overheating which has then led to the head cracking.
Now it could reasonably be asked:-
If you believe this to be true (and even if it could be proved) surely there would be a responsibility on your part to monitor the coolant temperature (assumed there is a gauge or at least an 'over heat' light) and stop the car before such damage occurred?
Sorry, it doesn't help your case, but no doubt the question will be asked.
Austin160 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Sep 14th, 2018, 15:10   #5
SwissXC90
Premier Member
 

Last Online: Mar 20th, 2024 19:26
Join Date: Jan 2016
Location: Cross Country
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Austin160 View Post
there would be a responsibility on your part to monitor the coolant temperature (assumed there is a gauge or at least an 'over heat' light) and stop the car before such damage occurred?
Very true. No car should overheat if the driver monitors the coolant temperature gauge properly
__________________
XC90 R-Design MY2009, Black Sapphire Metallic. HP-Sound, RSE, Nav, Tel, ParkingCam, BLIS, ParkingHeater, RestHeat, Removable Towbar, Summer: CRATUS 20x8 on Pirelli Scorpion Zeros 255/45, Winter: NEPTUNE 17x7 on Continental WinterContact 4x4 235/65.
SwissXC90 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Sep 14th, 2018, 16:24   #6
Clan
Experienced Member
 
Clan's Avatar
 

Last Online: Today 01:00
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: L/H side
Default

The car left their garage in January and has been fine for 7 months , So it can't have been cracked then .. What exactly happened regarding the recent overheat ? Did you let the temperature gauge go up far , how far and for how long? Hopefully heads are plentiful for these ..
__________________
My comments are only based on my opinions and vast experience .
Clan is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Sep 14th, 2018, 17:52   #7
iain cooper
Senior Member
 

Last Online: Dec 17th, 2021 13:26
Join Date: Apr 2015
Location: argyll and bute
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Clan View Post
The car left their garage in January and has been fine for 7 months , So it can't have been cracked then .. What exactly happened regarding the recent overheat ? Did you let the temperature gauge go up far , how far and for how long? Hopefully heads are plentiful for these ..
last January, 18 months ? even more difficult to prove a case.

Iain
__________________
MY15 XC60 D4 FWD SE LUX NAV Geartronic
iain cooper is offline   Reply With Quote
Old Sep 15th, 2018, 00:20   #8
ampy
Junior Member
 

Last Online: Mar 21st, 2024 22:31
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Cardiff
Default

It would be reasonable for the garage to ask how you allowed it to overheat to the stage that it was hot enough to crack the head, if indeed that was the sequence of events.
It would be very difficult for a court (or expert) to say whether the head was weakened long ago leading to needing a gasket replaced. The work could well have weakened it some more and eventually it just gave out. It would be very difficult to prove negligence against the garage in this case in my view.
ampy is offline   Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to ampy For This Useful Post:
Old Sep 15th, 2018, 09:39   #9
XC90Mk1
Premier Member
 

Last Online: Feb 16th, 2024 14:43
Join Date: May 2018
Location: Na
Default

Ok am with the orhers... I am sorry but the main thing is that if you pull over the instance the engine heats up or light illuminates this would prob not happen. Also it’s a fair time since they did the work.


I seem to be the only one asking this (genuinly) but

1). How do you prov a thermostat caused this. I understand that upon reaching heat the coolant does not circulate via the radiator as the thermostat has failed. I have had thermostats fail in the past but never led to this.

2). The real nail in the coffin to me is this.... your inspector will not be able to prove thermostat failures because the vehicle has overheated and will have meant the thermostat would have been subjected to excess heat. Question to
Inspector is did the thermostat fail or did the heat generated car we it to fail and you can not prove that.

What is wrong with a second hand pressure tested head rebuilt?
XC90Mk1 is offline   Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to XC90Mk1 For This Useful Post:
Old Sep 15th, 2018, 23:53   #10
ampy
Junior Member
 

Last Online: Mar 21st, 2024 22:31
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Cardiff
Default

You have just brought back an old memory. I had a stuck closed thermostat on a Morris 1000 van. It had been left standing for along time and I think corrosion got to it. It would be fine for 30 minutes driving and then the temperature would start to climb. It would then start to eject the coolant and there was plenty of steam to attract your attention to a problem. After pulling over and letting it cool I was able to remove the radiator cap. (Glad I used a big rag) I added water and made it home ok. I thought there was maybe an airlock that had caused the overheat and coolant loss. When it happened again the following day I knew there was a problem and eventually found the thermostat seized. Fitted a new one and never had a problem afterwards.
ampy is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:58.


Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.